Payment Reform Tests Positive

  • By carabernstein
  • in
  • on September 12, 2018

The below editorial is posted on behalf of Merrill Goozner, Editor Emeritus, Modern Healthcare. We are looking forward to welcoming Merrill at The Millennium Alliance Healthcare Payers Transformation Assembly in December.


New analyses of the major payment reforms begun during the Obama years suggest they do in fact lower healthcare spending. While the savings are small, they provide a strong argument for HHS Secretary Alex Azar to step up the pace of value-based reimbursement reform.

Two studies in the latest issue of JAMA looked at the early results from bundled payments for knee and hip replacements. Bundled payments cover all medical services during a well-defined episode of care. Hospitals earn a share of the savings if their costs are less than the bundle. They are penalized when they go over.

The knee-and-hip bundle became mandatory in 67 hospital markets in 2016. Another 332 hospitals took on that risk under a voluntary program that began in 2013.

The research on the mandatory program showed the CMS saved an average of $453 per case, or about 2% of the cost of the average bundle, without a diminution in quality. Most of the savings came from reduced spending on post-acute care, which can last up to 90 days.

A separate study of the voluntary program showed the CMS still saved money despite a small (although statistically insignificant) increase in the volume of surgeries. That’s of concern since there were fears that bundled payments would give hospitals making money under the program incentives to step up the pace of operations. So far, the increases, if any, appear to be minor.

That most hospitals in the mandatory program successfully adapted to the new payment regime offers the best evidence to date that the CMS can expand the scope of mandatory value-based reimbursement programs without putting hospital finances at risk. Alas, when Azar announced a proposed expansion of bundled payments to other care episodes earlier this year, he opted for a purely voluntary approach.

The latest accounting for the much-maligned accountable care organizations also should encourage the CMS to continue pushing toward more risk-based contracts. The vast majority (92%) of the 472 ACOs in the Medicare Shared Savings Program do not face downside risk if they go over the average Medicare patient’s costs.

About 60% of the ACOs in the program generated $1.1 billion in savings in 2017 with 70% of that going to the ACOs. Of course, that meant 40% of the provider networks went over the benchmarks.

That helps explain why many providers in the program still haven’t shown the fortitude to take on two-sided risk and why the CMS’ latest proposed rule calls for limiting hospitals to just two years in the risk-free model, down from the current six years. Graduation rates to Next Generation ACOs, where providers take on the greatest amount of risk, are disturbingly low. Just 51 networks have opted into the program that, in some cases, can include full capitated payments for the Medicare patients in their care.

When the Affordable Care Act created the CMS Innovation Center to push providers toward value-based care, shared savings programs were seen as the training wheels that would help providers learn how to take on risk. Trump administration officials are wrong to say the government is losing money under the program. But shortening the time period for upside-sharing-only participation is the right thing to do.

Given the recently enacted tax law and the continued graying of the population, the financial pressures on Medicare are only going to grow more intense in the years ahead. Some form of capitated payment is coming. That, in essence, is what the rapidly growing Medicare Advantage program run by private insurers offers the government.

Providers are eventually going to have to live within the limits set by capitated payments. They will be in a far better position to survive in that world if they learn the skills of managing risk.

See the article here.

About The Healthcare Payers Transformation Assembly

North America’s most prominent IT and business leaders from the Healthcare Insurance industry will be gathering in December to discuss how to adapt to the industry’s customer-centric makeover at Healthcare Payers Transformation Assembly in San Diego.

Download your copy of the sponsorship prospectus for more information>>

This is not just another “Healthcare” event. Spaces are reserved for the best in the business. Enquire about attendance here!

Leave a Reply

PUBLISHED BY carabernstein

View all posts by carabernstein

Related Posts

#MillenniumLive , Digital , Interview , Technology

#MillenniumLive on MACH Technology & Adapting to Change with Contentstack

This week on #MillenniumLive we’re joined by Sonja Kotrostos, the Head of European Go-To Markets at Contentstack. Sonja talks about Contentstack’s origins and how customer advocacy is at the core of their enterprise solutions. She also dives into how MACH technologies can enable brands to leverage APIs for seamless connectivity between systems, and how it’s […]

Security , Technology

New Technology to Help Fight Against the Global Pandemic

Mayank Varia, Research Scientist and Co-Director of Boston University’s Center for Reliable Information Systems & Cyber Security, has been working on brand new technology to trace COVID-19.  Mayank graciously answered some questions for us! Digital Contact tracing is on the cutting-edge of healthcare technology. Can you walk us through how this system works and the […]

Marketing , Retail

Contentstack’s Retail Marketing Personalization Roadmap: Building a Path to Higher Profitability

Retail marketing personalization isn’t limited to just the organizations that can pull off multi-year, multi-million-dollar technology projects. Personalization can start as simply as taking a day diving into data you already have and learning more about your customers on a personal level. But what does a powerful retail marketing personalization strategy look like? This ebook […]

Marketing

David Sable Takes a Deeper Look at What it Means to Think Outside the Box

As originally published by David Sable on Linkedin. Subscribe to the newsletter! To Think Outside the Box, Look Inwards “Think out of the box!” How many times have you heard that exhortation as a rallying cry to energize tired, old thinking? A phrase that, in my opinion, has become an overused synonym for innovation…like agile and modern. Not only is […]

Lovin’ Digital Diary?

Premium content to our readers interested in all things business.

Check Us Out!

Millennium Membership offers Fortune 1000 C-Level executives, leading public sector/government officials, and thought leaders across a variety of disciplines unique and exclusive opportunities to meet their peers, understand industry developments, and receive introductions to new technology and service advancements to help grow their career and overall company value.

About Millenium Alliance Next

About Digital Diary

Created to provide premium content to our readers interested in all things business.

Launched in 2017, Digital Diary was created to provide premium content to our readers interested in all things business. With our blogs catered to deliver the top news stories, trends, and interviews from across all industries.

Read all story Next

Interested in Millennium Membership?
Find out if you qualify here.

arrow